Jump to content

  • Log in with Facebook Log in with Twitter Log in with Windows Live Log In with Google      Sign In   
  • Create Account

Photo
- - - - -

imamat kissey karani chahiey?


  • Please log in to reply
35 replies to this topic

#1 unknown

unknown

    Ajmeri Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPip
  • 85 posts
  • Joined 16-September 08
  • Madhab:Hanafi

Posted 05 October 2008 - 02:38 AM

Posted Image
Hadees sharif ke mutabiq namaz parte waqat, na to kahin se kapdey fold honey chahiey, sar par topi bhi honi chahiey, paaon ke darmian taqreeban 4 unglion ka fasla bhi hona chahiey ya phir 1 foot se zayada nahin aur daddi bhi ek muthi se zayada honi chahiey.
ek shaks jis musaley mein namaz parney jata hai wahan par imamat aksar wo log karatey hain jin ki aksar daddi ek muthi se kam hoti hai sar pe topi nahi hoti, ya phir kapdey kahin se fold hotey hai ya phir paoon de darmian 1, 2 foot ka fasla hota hai.
agar koi aissa shaks imamat karaey jiss mein in 4 mein 2 ya 2 se zayada khamian hon, to kya us ke peechey namaz parni chahiey?

http://i50.tinypic.com/i3f82e.jpg


#2 Raza ka ghulam

Raza ka ghulam

    Ajmeri Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPip
  • 130 posts
  • Joined 30-July 08
  • Madhab:Hanafi

Posted 06 October 2008 - 04:09 PM

Posted Image
Hadees sharif ke mutabiq namaz parte waqat, na to kahin se kapdey fold honey chahiey, sar par topi bhi honi chahiey, paaon ke darmian taqreeban 4 unglion ka fasla bhi hona chahiey ya phir 1 foot se zayada nahin aur daddi bhi ek muthi se zayada honi chahiey.
ek shaks jis musaley mein namaz parney jata hai wahan par imamat aksar wo log karatey hain jin ki aksar daddi ek muthi se kam hoti hai sar pe topi nahi hoti, ya phir kapdey kahin se fold hotey hai ya phir paoon de darmian 1, 2 foot ka fasla hota hai.
agar koi aissa shaks imamat karaey jiss mein in 4 mein 2 ya 2 se zayada khamian hon, to kya us ke peechey namaz parni chahiey?




(wasalam)


Agar koi aissa shaks imamat karey jiss main ye khamiyan paye jaye tu us ke pihche namaaz nahi padni chahiye. Agar aisa koi shaks masjid main imamat kar raha hai tu foran use us masjid se nikaaliye aur kisi sahi imam ko laye taake logoun ki namaaz tu sahi adaa hojaye.


(ja)

#3 unknown

unknown

    Ajmeri Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPip
  • 85 posts
  • Joined 16-September 08
  • Madhab:Hanafi

Posted 06 October 2008 - 05:38 PM

yeh to bohat hi badi baat keh di aapne raza saab.
darasal wahan par koi bhi fix imam nahi rakha ja sakta fund ki kami ki wajah se, aur wahan par am tor par arbi log hi atey hai jo ke imamat karate hain, aur kabhi to un ke ilawa aur koi nahi hota imamat k liye.
aur merey sunaney mein yeh bhi aya hai ke wo salafi hain.
baraey meherabni zara mazeed roshni daliey aur agar mumkin ho sakey to imamat k kya faraiz hai wo bhi kissi fatwey ya hadees ke liaz se bata dijiey. shukrya!

http://i50.tinypic.com/i3f82e.jpg


#4 Sag-e-Attar

Sag-e-Attar

    Bahr-e-Huzn

  • Administrators

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,106 posts
  • Joined 14-June 06
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Pakistan
  • Madhab:Hanafi
  • Sheikh:Ameer-e-AhleSunnat

Posted 07 October 2008 - 02:10 AM

(salam)
Ager Imam Mein Imamat Ki Sharait Nhin Payi Jati Hain Tu Us Ko Namaz Perhana Aur Jisko Malom Hai Uska Perhna Darust Nhin.. Aur Imam Per Sab Ki Namaz Ka Gunah Hoga Key Baghair Masail Seekhey Imamat Ka Musallah Sanbhal Liya Aur Jisko Malom Tha Aur Namaz Perhi Uski Namaz Wajib ul Ae'adah Hai.. Dobarah Perhni Hogi..

Aik Muth Darhi Rakhna Wajib Hai.. Aur Is Sey Kam Waley Key Pechay Namaz Perhna Makrooh-e-Tehreemi Wajib ul Aeadah Hai..

Kaprey Fold Kerna Makrooh-e-Tehreemi Hai.. Aur Namaz Dobarah Lotani Hogi... Tu Aisey Imam Key Pechay Perhi Janey Wali Namaz Bhi Dobarah Perhni Hogi..

Aur Salafi Wahabi Deobandi Shia Kisi Badmazhab Key Pechay Namaz Nhin Hoti.. Jitni Perheen Sab Dobarah Perhni Hongi...

Is Liye Imam Ager Aapko Sahi Nhin Milta Tu Aap Jamaat Key Sath Namaz Na Perhein Tanha Perh Lein.. Mager Aisey Imam Key Pechay Namaz Na Perhein Jo Badmazhab Ho Ya Imamat Key masail Ka Ilm Na Rakhta Hoo...

Koi Aisa Masala Jis Sey Namaz Wajib ul Ae'adah Ho Rahi Hai Tu Woh Aik Khami Hi Kafi Hai.. Namaz Aap Aisey Imam Key Pechay Nhin perh Saktey..

Wassalam Ma'Al Ikram

#5 Bismillah

Bismillah

    Baghdadi Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 461 posts
  • Joined 13-August 08
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:canada
  • Madhab:Hanafi
  • Sheikh:Ameer-e-Ahlesunnat

Posted 07 October 2008 - 03:04 AM

(salam)
Zaid ne aaj musal’eh main ek shaks se poocha ke aap kis aqeedey se tauluq rakhatey hain to us ne jawab diya ke main sunni hoon aur main quran aur hadees ke mutabiq chalta hoon. Phir poochaney par us ne jawab diya ke main MALIKI hoon. aur hamarey han topi penana obligation nahi hai, aur namaz partey waqat hum apne paon ek doosrey namazi se mila kar rakhatey hain ta keh shaitaan na ajaey,

Dar'asal zaid north america mein rehta hai aur wahan par namaz Musal'ah mein pardi jati hai nake masjid mein, aur musal'ah mein taqreeban 5 se 15 tak log atey hain namaz ke liey, un mein se koi hanafi hotey aur koi maliki, lekin qasrat malikion ki hi hoti hai am tor par. ab musal'ah mein differents country's ke log hotey hain, koi pak sai hai, koi hind se hai, koi maroc se hai, aur aissey musal'eh mein koi bhi imam fix nahi kiya ja sakta. lihaza aissi surte-e-hal mein kabhi koi karda ho jata hai to kabhi koi. leikin am tor par wo log us ko kharda kartey hain jo zayada quran janta ho.

Ab zaid ko masla kuch hal hota hua nazar a raha hai, kyon ki SALAFI ek sunni sunai baat thi kissi se confirm nahi thi is liey zaid ulaj gaya tha.

1-) Ab aap mujhe bataiey ke koi HANAFI kissi MALIKI ke peechey namaz pard sakta hai?

2-) kya koi mujhe kissi imam ki koi SAHI hadees arbi mein de sakta hai jiss mein likha hua ho ke sar par topi penani chahiey ya nahi?

3-) kya zaid namaz ghar mein pard sakta hai? koi gunnah to nahi?

Edited by Bismillah, 07 October 2008 - 06:13 AM.


#6 Bismillah

Bismillah

    Baghdadi Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 461 posts
  • Joined 13-August 08
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:canada
  • Madhab:Hanafi
  • Sheikh:Ameer-e-Ahlesunnat

Posted 08 October 2008 - 04:10 AM

mujhe jawab bohat jald chahiey is masley ke barey mein, please
sag-e-attar bhai ke jawab ke mutabiq imamat ki 3 shartein hain, daddi ek muthi se zayada, kapdey fold nahi honey chahiey, aur bad mazhib na ho.
agar kissi ki qudarti tor par daddi kam ho to wo bechara kya kare?
kapdey to is liey fold kartey hain kyon k lambe bohat hotey hain, aur waissey bhi jab wo ghar se nikaltey hain unhen thoda hi pata hota hai ke aj namaz mujhe parani hogi wo to ghar se namaz paraney ke liey nikaltey hain imamat ke liey nahi.
alhumdulilah wo sunni hain salafi nahi.

ek aur baat, kya koi fatwey ya kissi hadees se yeh sabit kar sakta hai k jab kissi imamat karaney waley ka kapdey fold hon neechey se lamabai ki wajah se,(paint) us ke peechey pardi hui namaz dobara parni hogi?

#7 Raza ka ghulam

Raza ka ghulam

    Ajmeri Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPip
  • 130 posts
  • Joined 30-July 08
  • Madhab:Hanafi

Posted 08 October 2008 - 11:41 AM

yeh to bohat hi badi baat keh di aapne raza saab.
darasal wahan par koi bhi fix imam nahi rakha ja sakta fund ki kami ki wajah se, aur wahan par am tor par arbi log hi atey hai jo ke imamat karate hain, aur kabhi to un ke ilawa aur koi nahi hota imamat k liye.
aur merey sunaney mein yeh bhi aya hai ke wo salafi hain.
baraey meherabni zara mazeed roshni daliey aur agar mumkin ho sakey to imamat k kya faraiz hai wo bhi kissi fatwey ya hadees ke liaz se bata dijiey. shukrya!




(bis)

(salam)

Sag-e-Attar bhai ne jo jawaab diya hai wo bilkul sahi hai aur bahut hi achcha jawaab diya hai.

Aur aap ka jo masla hai ke wahan par imam fund par chalte hain to aap ke wahan area main dawat-e-islami wale tu honge kiyoun ke ye kai mumalik mian hain tu un se ye guzarish kariye aur puri baat bataye imam ke barey main tu wo zaroor wahan par kisi imam ko lagayein ge.

Aaap ka bakhi sawaal ka jawaab tu sag-e-attar bhai ne dediya hai.

(ja)

#8 Raza ka ghulam

Raza ka ghulam

    Ajmeri Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPip
  • 130 posts
  • Joined 30-July 08
  • Madhab:Hanafi

Posted 08 October 2008 - 11:54 AM

(salam)
Zaid ne aaj musal’eh main ek shaks se poocha ke aap kis aqeedey se tauluq rakhatey hain to us ne jawab diya ke main sunni hoon aur main quran aur hadees ke mutabiq chalta hoon. Phir poochaney par us ne jawab diya ke main MALIKI hoon. aur hamarey han topi penana obligation nahi hai, aur namaz partey waqat hum apne paon ek doosrey namazi se mila kar rakhatey hain ta keh shaitaan na ajaey,

Dar'asal zaid north america mein rehta hai aur wahan par namaz Musal'ah mein pardi jati hai nake masjid mein, aur musal'ah mein taqreeban 5 se 15 tak log atey hain namaz ke liey, un mein se koi hanafi hotey aur koi maliki, lekin qasrat malikion ki hi hoti hai am tor par. ab musal'ah mein differents country's ke log hotey hain, koi pak sai hai, koi hind se hai, koi maroc se hai, aur aissey musal'eh mein koi bhi imam fix nahi kiya ja sakta. lihaza aissi surte-e-hal mein kabhi koi karda ho jata hai to kabhi koi. leikin am tor par wo log us ko kharda kartey hain jo zayada quran janta ho.

Ab zaid ko masla kuch hal hota hua nazar a raha hai, kyon ki SALAFI ek sunni sunai baat thi kissi se confirm nahi thi is liey zaid ulaj gaya tha.

1-) Ab aap mujhe bataiey ke koi HANAFI kissi MALIKI ke peechey namaz pard sakta hai?

2-) kya koi mujhe kissi imam ki koi SAHI hadees arbi mein de sakta hai jiss mein likha hua ho ke sar par topi penani chahiey ya nahi?

3-) kya zaid namaz ghar mein pard sakta hai? koi gunnah to nahi?



(bis)

(wasalam)

1. Nahi.

2. Check kar ke bataounga. Agar kisi Bahi ko pata ho tu share kijiye.

3. Agar khareeb main Ahlesunnat ki masjid ho ya koi sahi imam hoto wahan pade ghar main padne se gunah hoga. Agar aisi masjid ya imam na hotu wo namaaz ghar main hi ada kary gunah na hoga namaaz hojayegi.

#9 Raza ka ghulam

Raza ka ghulam

    Ajmeri Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPip
  • 130 posts
  • Joined 30-July 08
  • Madhab:Hanafi

Posted 08 October 2008 - 12:04 PM

mujhe jawab bohat jald chahiey is masley ke barey mein, please
sag-e-attar bhai ke jawab ke mutabiq imamat ki 3 shartein hain, daddi ek muthi se zayada, kapdey fold nahi honey chahiey, aur bad mazhib na ho.
agar kissi ki qudarti tor par daddi kam ho to wo bechara kya kare?
kapdey to is liey fold kartey hain kyon k lambe bohat hotey hain, aur waissey bhi jab wo ghar se nikaltey hain unhen thoda hi pata hota hai ke aj namaz mujhe parani hogi wo to ghar se namaz paraney ke liey nikaltey hain imamat ke liey nahi.
alhumdulilah wo sunni hain salafi nahi.

ek aur baat, kya koi fatwey ya kissi hadees se yeh sabit kar sakta hai k jab kissi imamat karaney waley ka kapdey fold hon neechey se lamabai ki wajah se,(paint) us ke peechey pardi hui namaz dobara parni hogi?



(bis)

(salam)

Bhai namaaz ki sirf 3 shartein nahi hain kai hain jab tak namaaz ke , wazu ke aur paki ke is jaise tamam masle jo namaaz ke liye zaroori hai un masloun ka jaannah zaroori hai jab ja ke wo namaaz pada sakta hai.

Aap ek kaam ye karein ke Aap khud BAHAR-E-SHARIYAT KE 5 HISSE PAD LEIN AUR PURE MASLE YAAD KAR LEIN TO AAP KHUD NAMAAZ PADA SAKTE HAIN YE BOOK AAP KO ONLINE MIL JAYEGI IS KITAAB KO ZAROOR PADEIN.


agar kissi ki qudarti tor par daddi kam ho to wo bechara kya kare?


AGAR KISI KI QUDRATI TOUR PAR DADDI KAM HO TO WO NAMAAZ PADA SAKTA HAIN YE ALAG MASLA HAI MAGAR WO DADDI BADNE KE BAWAJOOD KAATTA HAI TU WOS KE PEHCHE NAMAAZ NAHI HOGI.


kapdey to is liey fold kartey hain kyon k lambe bohat hotey hain, aur waissey bhi jab wo ghar se nikaltey hain unhen thoda hi pata hota hai ke aj namaz mujhe parani hogi wo to ghar se namaz paraney ke liey nikaltey hain imamat ke liey nahi.


SAB SE PEHLE TU WOTNE LAMBE KAPDE NAHI PEHNA CHAHIYE AGAR PEHAN BHI LIYE TO WOS KO FOLD NA KAREIN WAISE HI CHOD DEIN NAMAAZ HOJAYE GI.

CHAHE IMAMAT KARY YA NAMAAZ PADE DONOUN KE LIYE YE ZAROORI HAI KE KAPDE NA FOLD KAREIN.

MAIN SAMAJTA HOUN KE AAP KE JAWAAB CLEAR HOGAYE HONGE AGAR KUCH MASLA NAHI SAMAJ MAIN AAYA TO PHIR SE SAWAAL KAR SAKTE HAIN.

(ja)

#10 Bismillah

Bismillah

    Baghdadi Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 461 posts
  • Joined 13-August 08
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:canada
  • Madhab:Hanafi
  • Sheikh:Ameer-e-Ahlesunnat

Posted 08 October 2008 - 04:37 PM

bohat shukrya raza saab!
1-) aap ne kaha ke koi hanafi kissi maliki ke peeche namaz nahi pard sakta, kyon? halan k dono sahi aqeedey par hai aur dono hi ahlesunnat se hain. is baat ko aap kissi hadees se sabit kar saktey hai?

2-) jahan pe mein rehta hoon wahan par koi bhi dawat-e-islami ka koi nahi hai merey khial se.

3-) mus'alh to qareeb hi hai lekin wahan par am tor imamat Maliki hi karatey hain

#11 Bismillah

Bismillah

    Baghdadi Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 461 posts
  • Joined 13-August 08
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:canada
  • Madhab:Hanafi
  • Sheikh:Ameer-e-Ahlesunnat

Posted 09 October 2008 - 02:31 AM

1-) agar assi baat hoti ke koi hanafi kissi maliki k peeche namaz nahi pard sakta, tab to khana kaaba mein jitne bhi 4 mein 3 fiqey waley hain une ki to namaz hi nahi hogi merey khial se.
kyon ki khana kaba mein jo imamat karata hai, wo imam bhi 4 mein se kissi ek fiqey se hai, farz karein k MALIKI hai, aur baqi jo hanafi, shafi aur hanbali us ke peechey namaz pard rahey hain, un ka kya?

2-) kya koi sahi hadees se sabit kar sakta hai ke, imam ki pant agar neechey se thordi si fold ho to peechey waley ko dobara namaz parni hogi?

#12 Raza ka ghulam

Raza ka ghulam

    Ajmeri Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPip
  • 130 posts
  • Joined 30-July 08
  • Madhab:Hanafi

Posted 10 October 2008 - 03:55 PM

bohat shukrya raza saab!
1-) aap ne kaha ke koi hanafi kissi maliki ke peeche namaz nahi pard sakta, kyon? halan k dono sahi aqeedey par hai aur dono hi ahlesunnat se hain. is baat ko aap kissi hadees se sabit kar saktey hai?

2-) jahan pe mein rehta hoon wahan par koi bhi dawat-e-islami ka koi nahi hai merey khial se.

3-) mus'alh to qareeb hi hai lekin wahan par am tor imamat Maliki hi karatey hain



(bis)

(salam)

1. Isliye ke wo logoun ka tariqa alag hai aur apna tariqa alag hai har fiqahi masle main ekhtelaf hai is liye un ke piche namaaz nahi pad sakte. G dono hi nahi balke 4 imamoun ko maane wale sab sahi hain aur sab Ahlesunnat hi hain magar in char imamoun ki bich kai fiqahi masle main ikhtelaafaat hain jaise ke ek imam ke nazdeek pure sarka masah karna zaroori hai aur ek imam ke nazdeek sirf kuch baal jhoone se masah hojata hai aur Apne imam ka masla ye hai ke chohtaye sar ka masah karne se masah hota hai.

Tu ab aap bataye ke jab tak chohtaye sar ka masah na karein wazu na hoga tu wo imam ke maane wale sirf kuch baal ko cho lein to un ka tu wazu hogaya magar hamare nazdeek un ka wazu hi nahi howa tu jis ka wazu hi nahi howa us ki namaaz kaise hogi aur imam ki hi namaaz na hoto muqtadi ki kaise hogi. Isi tarha kai masloun main ikhtelaaf hai. ye hi wajah hai ke un ke pehche namaaz nahi hoti.



2. Nahi bhai aap check karein waha koi tu hoga Dawat-e-Islami wale kiyoun ke ye kai mulkoun main hain taqreeban 50 ya 60 tu wahan bhi hounge. Waise aap kahan rehte hain.

3. Jahan par Imam sahi na ho tu wahan namaaz na pade jamaat ke saat , Alag ghar par hi ada karein ho jayegi.


UMEED KARTA HOUN KE AAP SAMAJ GAYE HOUNGE. AGAR KUCH AUR SAWALAAT HAIN TU PUCH SAKTE HAIN. AGAR KISI BHAI KO MERE IN REPLY MAIN ISLAH KI ZAROORAT LAGE TO ZAROOR KIJIYEGA.

(ja)

#13 Raza ka ghulam

Raza ka ghulam

    Ajmeri Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPip
  • 130 posts
  • Joined 30-July 08
  • Madhab:Hanafi

Posted 10 October 2008 - 04:10 PM

1-) agar assi baat hoti ke koi hanafi kissi maliki k peeche namaz nahi pard sakta, tab to khana kaaba mein jitne bhi 4 mein 3 fiqey waley hain une ki to namaz hi nahi hogi merey khial se.
kyon ki khana kaba mein jo imamat karata hai, wo imam bhi 4 mein se kissi ek fiqey se hai, farz karein k MALIKI hai, aur baqi jo hanafi, shafi aur hanbali us ke peechey namaz pard rahey hain, un ka kya?

2-) kya koi sahi hadees se sabit kar sakta hai ke, imam ki pant agar neechey se thordi si fold ho to peechey waley ko dobara namaz parni hogi?



(bis)

(salam)

1. Agar Imam e Azam ke maane wale yani hanafi ke pihche dosre 3 imam ke maane waloun ki namaaz ho jaye gi . Magar hanafi ki namaaz in 3 ke pihche nahi hogi. Aur imam e Kaba ke pihche namaaz nahi hogi alag padna hoga ya alag jamaat bana ke sahi imam ke pihche padiye. kiyoun ke wahan par jo imam hai wo imam e Shafi ke maane wale hai sahed. Tu wahan par aap ko alag namaaz padni hai ye yaad rakhye.


2. Is main maine tu sirf aalimoun se suna hai aur fatwa bhi dekha hai main is par hadees nahi padi isliye main aap ko hadees ke barey main tu nahi bata sakta AGAR KISI ISLAMI BHAI KE PASS HAI TO PLS SHARE KAREIN.

Paint fold kar ke padna makru-e-tehreemi hai isliye Namaaz daurani padegi. Aur taqne ke neeche tak agar hai paint tu waise hi chod dein namaaz hojaye gi ye Makru-e-tanzeemi hai.is se namaaz hojati hai.

Ye masla mujeh maloom tha main ne aap ko bata diya.

Agar phir bhi aap ko kuch samaj na aaye tu aap sawaal kar sakte hain.


(ja)

#14 Bismillah

Bismillah

    Baghdadi Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 461 posts
  • Joined 13-August 08
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:canada
  • Madhab:Hanafi
  • Sheikh:Ameer-e-Ahlesunnat

Posted 10 October 2008 - 10:00 PM

asalamo alekum!
bohat shukrya aap ke jawabat ka!
location montreal, canada.
1-) aap ne kaha ke aur 3 imamon ko manane walon ki namaz kissi hanafi imam ke peeche ho jaey gi, merey khial se un 4 mein se 1 imam aissa bhi hai jin k nazdeeq sare sar ka masah karna hoga, lekin hanafi to sirf chotahi sar ka masah karte hai, to phir agar koi hanafi imamat karaey to phir us ki shaks ke nazdeeq jo sare sar ka masah karta hai hanafi ki namaz to nahi ho gi na, lekin apne kaha ke teeno ki ho jaey gi kissi hanafi ke peechey. wo kaissey?

2-) bohat sare log hajh k liey jatey hain aur wo sab namaz ke waqat ek hi imam ke peechey namaz partey hain, kabhi aapne aissa dekha sunna hai k koi hajh k liey gaya aur farz namaz parney k liey us ne koi hanafi imam na milne ki waja se akele hi namaz pard li kyon k khana kaba ka imam hanfi nahi hai. ab kissi ko wahan ki zaban nahi ati to wo bechara kya karey ga, usey to phir akele hi namaz parni ho gi na jamat k saath nahi. kyon k bohat sare log jo haj ko jate hain un mein se aksar ko to yeh bhi nahi pata hota ke imam kissey kehtey hain aur hamara imam kon hai. maaf karna bhai, mujhe aapke jawab mein koi sens nazar nahi a rahi, please dont mind, u r like my brother.

3-) mumkin hai k imamon ke darmian ikhtilaaf ho, lekin sajda to 1 allah ko karna hai na, chahey koi hanfi ho ya shafi, sajda to sab ek jaissa kartey hai na.

4-) tariqa chahey kissi ka koi bhi ho, important to yeh hai ke namaz parney wala Ahelesunnat se ho aur sahi aqeedey wala bhi ho, aur alhumdulillah 4 imamon ko mananey waley ahlesunnat se hai aur sahi aqeedey waley bhi.

merey khial se 4 imam to iss liey hain na ke nabi paak salalaho alehey wasalam ki sari sunnatein ada ho jayen. example: hamarey aqa salalaho alehey wasalam kabhi naaf ke neechey haath bandetey they aur kabhi seeney ke uper namaz ke waqat, to agar sarey ahelesunnat waley sirf hanafi hotey, tab to sab ne haath naf ke neechey bandaney they, to is tarah se jab nabi paak salalaho alehey wasalam namaz mein haath seeney par rakh kar par partey they to is sunnat par to koi amal na karta na? to issi liey 4 imam hain ta k nabi paak salalaho alehey wasalam ki sari sunnatein ada ho jayen merey khial se.


charon imamon ke chahey tariqey alehda hon, lekin jard to ek hi hai na ke sajda allah ko karna hai, to phir koi kaisse keh sakta hai ke main to hanfi hoon aur meri namaz kissi hanbali ke peechey nahi ho gi.

aap masjid mein jatey hain aur wahan par 10 shafi namaz ke liey khardey ho gaey aur aap ne apni namaz alehda akele parni shuru kar di aur unhon ne jamat ke saath. namaz ke baad unhon ne aap se poocha ke aap ne namaz kyon akele pardi aur aap agar jawab de k mein to hanfi hoon shafi nahi, to zahiri baat hai aap un se qata tualiq kar rahey hain.

masjid mein 10 , 10 log charon fiqon se hain, namaz ka waqat hua to phir azan kon dega, is hisaab se to hanafi alheda azan de ga aur shafi waley alehda, issi tara wo apni jamat alheda khardi karein gey aur hanafi waley alehda.

merey khial se alhedagi shaitaan kon pasand hai allah aur us ke rasool allah salalaho alehey wasalam ko nahi.
to bataiey ke allah ke ghar mein a kar 2 musalman alehda ho gaey to kya allah ko yeh passand ho ga?

meri koi baat kissi ko buri lagi ho to main maafi ka talibgar hoon.

#15 Bismillah

Bismillah

    Baghdadi Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 461 posts
  • Joined 13-August 08
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:canada
  • Madhab:Hanafi
  • Sheikh:Ameer-e-Ahlesunnat

Posted 20 October 2008 - 05:36 PM

is fatwey mein reaayat ki baat ki gai hai, kya murad hai is se?

Click here! Fatwa about this Masla,

Edited by Bismillah, 20 October 2008 - 05:37 PM.


#16 Bismillah

Bismillah

    Baghdadi Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 461 posts
  • Joined 13-August 08
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:canada
  • Madhab:Hanafi
  • Sheikh:Ameer-e-Ahlesunnat

Posted 27 December 2008 - 11:36 PM

1.) yeh mujhe bahar-e-shariat wali kitab se mila hai lekin pard kar confus ho gaya hoon, is mein likha hai keh doosrey muqalid ki iqtada us waqat jaiz hai jab wo hamarey mazhib ki riayat karta ho aur neechey likha hai keh agar nahi pata keh doosrey muqalid ka imam riayat karta hai ya nahi to us ki iqtada jaiz hai,
2.) yeh kaissey pata chaley k us ne riayat ki hai ya nahi? wo to namaz para raha hai,

Posted Image

Edited by Bismillah, 28 December 2008 - 12:22 AM.


#17 Bismillah

Bismillah

    Baghdadi Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 461 posts
  • Joined 13-August 08
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:canada
  • Madhab:Hanafi
  • Sheikh:Ameer-e-Ahlesunnat

Posted 30 December 2008 - 06:05 PM

Kya koi tafseel se is fatwey ko mujhe samjah sakta hai? yani k is ki ek ek baat,
Posted Image

#18 Bismillah

Bismillah

    Baghdadi Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 461 posts
  • Joined 13-August 08
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:canada
  • Madhab:Hanafi
  • Sheikh:Ameer-e-Ahlesunnat

Posted 28 January 2010 - 04:03 PM

merey khial say yeh masla abhi tak hal nahi hua



#19 Usman Razawi

Usman Razawi

    Super Moderator

  • Super Moderator

  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,825 posts
  • Joined 12-April 09
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Terra Firma
  • Madhab:Hanafi
  • Sheikh:Huzoor Tajushariah

Posted 28 January 2010 - 04:09 PM

merey khial say yeh masla abhi tak hal nahi hua




bra-e-mehrbani Apnay Mas'la likhiay , topic bhut lamba hay poora parhna zra mushkil hay lihaza aap jo poochna chahtay hain dobara likhiay , bhut bhut shukria....

نبی پاک صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کے اسم گرامی یا آپ کی صفت کے ساتھ پورا صلٰوۃوسلام لکھنا واجب ہے اور ص یا صلعم لکھنا مکروہ تحریمی ہے ، بلکہ بعض فقہا نے اس کو کفر کہا ہے ، لہذا اس سے اجتناب لازم ہے..مزید تفصیل کے لیے کلک کریں

Nabi PakKay Ism-e-Girami Ya Aap Ki Sift Kay Saath Poora Salat-O-Salam Likhna Wajib Hay Aor SAW , PBUH ص، صلعم Likhna Makrooh-e-Tahreemi Hay Balkeh Baaz Fuqha Nay Isko Kufr Kaha Hay , Lihaza Is Say Ijtenab Lazim Hay.It is Necessary (Wajib) to Write Complete Salat-o-Salam at the mentioning of the Messenger of Allah (Blessings And Peace Be Upon Him)) And using abbreviations (SAW , PUBH etc) Is Not Allowed , And To do so is Kufr , According To Some Scholar's Opinion. So We Should Avoid Using Abbrevations Or sufficing on one of the two, i.e. Salat (Blessings) & Salam (Peace).Correct Translation Of صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم

#20 Bismillah

Bismillah

    Baghdadi Member

  • Members

  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 461 posts
  • Joined 13-August 08
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:canada
  • Madhab:Hanafi
  • Sheikh:Ameer-e-Ahlesunnat

Posted 28 January 2010 - 06:27 PM

masla to imamat kay mutabiq hi hai. lekin agar 5 10 minut laga agar shuru say parna shuru karein gay to yaqeenan aap ko masla behtar samjh aey ga.
iss maslay ko octobre 2008 main post kiya gaya tha lekin aj jan 2010 a gaya lekin yeh masla abhi tak hal nahi hua. kyon keh is ka koi tasali bakhash jawab nahi mil paya.

Edited by Bismillah, 28 January 2010 - 06:29 PM.






Similar Topics Collapse

  Topic Forum Started By Stats Last Post Info

 

0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users