Articles and Books

274 topics in this forum

1. Ahlalhdeeth Karji Says: Ibn Umar (Radi Allahu Anhum) Contradicts The Messenger (Alehis Salam), And Not Caliph, We Have No Obligation To Follow Him

   By MuhammedAli, March 27   

   • Do you offer the Duha prayer
   • Did `Umar use to pray it?
   • (and 8 more)

     Tagged with:

     • Do you offer the Duha prayer
     • Did `Umar use to pray it?
     • It is an innovation.
     • what a fine innovation it is
     • Salat ad-Duha
     • every innovation is misguidan
     • see it as something good
     • evil affairs are the innovati
     • did not innovate anything
     • dearer to me than that prayer
   • 1 reply
   • 278 views
   • 
   • MuhammedAli
   • March 31

2. Ibn Umar's Statement Regarding Salat ad-Duha Establishes He Believed Shar'ri Good Innovations Are Legitimate In Islam

   By MuhammedAli, March 22   

   • Salat ad-Duhagood innovation
   • two rakaat of Duha
   • (and 7 more)

     Tagged with:

     • Salat ad-Duhagood innovation
     • two rakaat of Duha
     • It is an innovation
     • nd what a fine innovation it
     • the people did not innovate
     • earer to me than that prayer
     • Prophet offering the Duha
     • prayer but I always offer it
     • Aisha whether the Messenger
   • 1 reply
   • 216 views
   • 
   • M Afzal Razvi
   • March 22

3. Responding To The Claim –: Ibn Umar Believed Salat Ad-Duha Is Prophetic Sunnah.

   By MuhammedAli, March 15   

   • Salat ad-Duhainnovation
   • Ibn Umar
   • (and 7 more)

     Tagged with:

     • Salat ad-Duhainnovation
     • Ibn Umar
     • fine innovation
     • innovate anything that dear
     • what a fine innovation it is!
     • Masjid Quba
     • Salafi
     • Wahhabi
     • Sufi
   • 0 replies
   • 205 views
   • 
   • MuhammedAli
   • March 15

4. Establishing Ibn Umar’S Definition Of Innovation And Addressing Shaykh Aymen’S Linguistic Innovation Claim.

   By MuhammedAli, March 12   

   • Biddah
   • Salat ad-Duha
   • (and 7 more)

     Tagged with:

     • Biddah
     • Salat ad-Duha
     • linugistic innovation
     • shari innovation
     • good innovation
     • innovation
     • evil innovation
     • Aymen bin Khaled
     • AhlalHdeeth
   • 0 replies
   • 177 views
   • 
   • MuhammedAli
   • March 12

5. Natural Understanding Of: ‘It Is An Innovation And What A Fine Innovation It Is!’ Distorted By Shaykh Ayman Bin Khaled.

   By MuhammedAli, March 2
   • 0 replies
   • 182 views
   • 
   • MuhammedAli
   • March 2

6. Argument: Major Shirk Is From Major Sins. So How Do You Justify Exclusion Of Prostration Of Reverance From Major Shirk?

   By MuhammedAli, January 30
   • 0 replies
   • 273 views
   • 
   • MuhammedAli
   • January 30

7. Prostration As Mark Of Respect Prohibited Due To Being Shirk Or Being Haram.

   By MuhammedAli, January 22
   • 0 replies
   • 237 views
   • 
   • MuhammedAli
   • January 22

8. Response To Sister Umm Abdullah On Issue Of Khariji Belief; Polytheists Believed In Tawheed Al Rububiyyah.

   By MuhammedAli, January 22
   • 0 replies
   • 262 views
   • 
   • MuhammedAli
   • January 22

9. Responding To Argument; Hadith Of Tirmadhi, Indicating Erroneous Innovation, Is Weak.

   By MuhammedAli, November 7, 2016
   • 0 replies
   • 307 views
   • 
   • MuhammedAli
   • November 7, 2016

10. Adressing Position Of Shaykh Al-Zaman, Mentioned In Commentary Of Muslim On Hadith Of Good/evil Sunnah.

    By MuhammedAli, November 4, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 331 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • November 4, 2016

11. The Shar’Ri Judgment Regarding Smoking Of Tabbaco Products.

    By MuhammedAli, November 2, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 280 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • November 2, 2016

12. Refuting The Claim; Hadith Of Good/evil Sunnah Refers To Reward Worthy Actions And Sinful Actions.

    By MuhammedAli, October 18, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 372 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • October 18, 2016

13. Responding To Incorrect Understandings Presented By Al Qarni And Al-Ajlan On Hadith Of Good/evil Sunnah.

    By MuhammedAli, October 18, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 349 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • October 18, 2016

14. Refuting Ibn Fawzans Claim; Taraweeh, Compiling Quran, Books Of Hadith Not Good Innovations – Part Two

    By MuhammedAli, October 8, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 350 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • October 8, 2016

15. Erroneous Understanding Of Words Of Hadith: Whatever The Muslims View As Good Is Good In The Sight Of Allah.

    By MuhammedAli, October 1, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 379 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • October 1, 2016

16. Refuting Al-Bani’S Criticism Against Islamic Understanding: Whatever The Muslims View As Good/evil, Is Soin The Sight Of Allah.

    By MuhammedAli, October 1, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 302 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • October 1, 2016

17. Determining Good/evil Sunnah In Light Of: Whatever The Muslims View As Good/evil, Is So In The Sight Of Allah.

    By MuhammedAli, October 1, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 246 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • October 1, 2016

18. Innovation Into Religion And Worship: Companion Introduces New Another Tasbih.

    By MuhammedAli, August 30, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 1,011 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • August 30, 2016

19. Innovation Into Religion And Worship: Established From Hadith Of Abdullah Ibn Mas’Ud.

    By MuhammedAli, August 29, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 337 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • August 29, 2016

20. Khawarij Bluring The Distinction Between ‘Grave-Worship’ And Quranic Persona-Worship – And The Reason For It.

    By MuhammedAli, August 26, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 323 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • August 26, 2016

21. Disscussions On Hadith Of – O Servants Of Allah Help Me.

    By MuhammedAli, August 4, 2015
    • 2 replies
    • 979 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • August 18, 2016

22. Kharijism And Wahhabism – Takfir Of Muslims Due To Their Sinful Actions.

    By MuhammedAli, August 12, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 380 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • August 12, 2016

23. Refuting The Notion That Prostration By Its Very Nature Is Worship.

    By MuhammedAli, August 9, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 298 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • August 9, 2016

24. Seveteen Points Which Indicate The Direction And Location Of Historical Najd.

    By MuhammedAli, August 7, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 349 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • August 7, 2016

25. Refuting Argument – If Shirk In Ummah Is Impossible So Is Poverty Impossible.

    By MuhammedAli, August 6, 2016
    • 0 replies
    • 421 views
    • 
    • MuhammedAli
    • August 6, 2016