iamHanfi

Qadri sab, pls tell me app duniya ki kon c zuban samajtay hain jo mairi baat app ko samaj nahe arahe, first you told me that you believe Hazzrat Mohammad SAW is BASHIR then i post a reply where it is write if any one say bashir becomes kafir es k baad tum ny koe aur bakwas start kar di that see related topic. QADRI SAB if you courage then pls pls apna aqeeda URDU main type kar k post karo then main koe baat karon tum pahly he bagh chukay ho apni pahly baat say in which you siad we belive in Bashir then said see our aqeeda in related topic. Idahr udhar ki baat mat karna sirf sirf apna aqeeda lekh kar post karo URDU Main. Baki us topic ko main study kia ha, app sab barelvi milkar b Sajjad khan ki baatoon ka jawab nahe depar rahy. Magar mujy es say concern nahe i only want your aqeeda in urdu then talk to me, if you can not post your aqeeda then i am not here to reply you because if i write something then you will again said see related topic. so if you will post then i will talk to you and one thing more also write all others aqeeda is not ur that is mentioned in my post.

Salar Raza, tum sab aqal say khali ho, mainy tum say jo sawal kia ha us ka jawab 2, aur apni kissi kitab ki scan mat karna, only fika book. baki sacn k baad baat ho gi.

Salar Raza, Pciture laga kar tum nay ye sabit karnay ki koshish ki ha k, Imam Abu Hanifa nay jab Fatawa diya tha tab all type of Crow ko dykah phir fatwa di. Imam Sab nay to fatwa main sirf 3type of crow ka zikar kia tha. Mairi app say request ha k app Fika ki book ko scan kar 2 jahan lekha ho k jo Color walay crow tum nay mentioned kia ha wo halal ha aur 2sara crow jo HALAL aur HARAM bi khata ho magar haram ha aur color black be mentioned ho. mary alfaz ghoor say study karna aur book scan kardaina. Warna ab reply karkay maira aur apny waqat mat zaya karo.

Qadri, Ankhan khool kar tum paro, tum nay mentioned kia tha k jo Bashir na jayny wo kafir magar yahan clearly lekha ha jo bashir jany wo kafir. aur baki tum ny pher wohe baat ki aur phir lekha Noor Bashir walay topic par explaination par loo main kahta hoon tum be Mulana Safdar sab ki book Masla Noor Bashir par loo jahan par barlvion ko tamachay paray hain.

Attari Sab, Jawab ka intazar karnay k thanks. apkay nazdeek 10000000% us ko kafir kehte ho jo Huzoor ko Bashar nahi manta magar app ka bary tou kuch aur he farmatay hain. Kinzul iman Ahmed Raza +Naeem din ka Tarjama aur tafseer, lekha ha Quran main Imbia ko Bahsir kahnay walay ko Kafir lekha gia ha, actual ibarat khdu paraloo. sirf aik hawala he kafi ha.

HO Jahallo baat crow ki ha kissi kutta ki nahe jo Islam main haram ha magar barelviat main sirf Laib najis ha. Crow 3 kisam ka ha 1) jo halla khata ha (Jaiz ha to eat) 2) jo haram khata ha (Haram ha to eat) 3) jo Hallal aur haram khata ha (Jaiz ha to eat) Below ibarat if wrong ha then confirm karo. <!--sizeo:5--><span style="font-size:18pt;line-height:100%"><!--/sizeo--><!--fonto:Tahoma--><span style="font-family:Tahoma"><!--/fonto-->وَالْغُرَابُ ثَلَاثَةُ أَنْوَاعٍ : نَوْعٌ يَأْكُلُ الْجِيَفَ فَحَسْبُ فإنه لَا يُؤْكَلُ وَنَوْعٌ يَأْكُلُ الْحَبَّ فَقَطْ فإنه يُؤْكَلُ وَنَوْعٌ يَخْلِطُ بَيْنَهُمَا وهو أَيْضًا يُؤْكَلُ عِنْدَ أبي حَنِيفَةَ وهو الْعَقْعَقُ لِأَنَّهُ كَالدَّجَاجِ وَعَنْ أبي يُوسُفَ رَحِمَهُ اللَّهُ أَنَّهُ يُكْرَهُ لِأَنَّ غَالِبَ مَأْكُولِهِ الْجِيَفُ وَالْأَوَّلُ أَصَحُّ (تبيين الحقائق، باب الخلع، جزء5 صفحه295)يه هے حواله طباعت: دار الکتب الاسلامي<!--fontc--></span><!--/fontc--><!--sizec--></span><!--/sizec--> مفهوم اس عبارت کا يه هے که کوے کي تين اقسام هيں 1۔ وه جو صرف حلال اشياء کھاتا هے اسکو کھانا بالاتفاق حلال هے۔ 2۔ وه جو صرف حرام کھاتا هے اسکو کھانا بالاتفاق حرام هے۔ 3۔ وه کوا جو حلال اور حرام دونوں قسم کي اشياء کھاتا هے۔ يه امام صاحب کے نزديک جائز هے۔ اور امام ابو يوسف کے نزديک اسے کھانا مکروه هے ۔ اور صاحب کتاب نے فرمايا هے که امام ابو حنيفه رحمه الله کا قول زياده بهتر هے۔ اب خود هي ديکھ لو که کس کي بات کو ماننا هے۔ هم تو حنفي هيں امام صاحب کي بات کو مانتے هيں۔ اور مولانا رشيد احمد گنگوهي بھي حنفي تھے اسلئے انهوں نے اس مسئله کو امام صاحب سے نقل کيا هے۔

Attari Sab, Aisay nahe hota, i need reply of my question, i am repeating again. In our city there is a crow how eat Hallal and haram food, aur shikar b nahe karta. tell me this crow is Halal to eat or Haram.????? i do not need explaination just yes or not

Chesti Qadri, main phaly b kah chuka hoon k ap ka brelvi bahi rules and regulation ki khalif warzi karaha ha but mujo ko warning dytay ho barelvi k lia naram goshka kun. Attari: i need your reply Q: Hazrat Mohammad SA noor hain YES/NOT select anyone Q: Hazrat Mohammad SA bashir hain YES/NOT select anyone

Qadri Attari, legata ha k app ki akal bohat moti ha jo mairi small c baat app ki samah dani main nahe arahe. wohan mentioned ha k BIdati Barelvion ka aqeeda ha k Hazzart Mohammd SA noor hain. agar tou tum bidati Hazzrat Mohammad Ko noor nahe mantay to bato aur mentioned karo k tum Hazrat Mohammad SA ko Bashir mantay ho aur wohan galat lekha ha. Main koe aisi baat nahr kar raha jo tumhar MOTI AQAL MAIN NA AYE. agar tumhar aqeeda ha noor ka ha tou wohan 100% right lekha ha agar bashir ka ha then tum itraz karo k ham Hazrat Mohammad SA ko bashir mantay hain. AB idhar udhar ki baat na karna jawab han ya na main do taky main agay baat karon. Hazrat Mohammad Noor hain yan BASHIR reply me. Fazool reply na karna agar tumhar aqal jawab nahe dyrahe tou kisi aur chisti Qadri say mashwara karo Koe bidati barlvi ab mujy ye na kahay k ye related topic ha yan nahe

Barelvio, mainy jo post ki ha mujy serf eska jawab 2 Salar Raza and ALI tumko shayad samaj nahe ati, mainy sawal kia tha k, in our city there is a crow how eat Hallal and Haram food aur shakar b nahe karta. mairay sawal ka jawab dyna k this crow will be halla to eat reply me yes or not. Do not tell me the defination of Zarghay maroofa so and so on.

Attari Sab, yeh baat jo app sab barelvi mujko bar bar kahrahe ho, apnay barelvi qadri ko kun nahe samjatay jo topic say unrelated baat karta ha but why u not talk to ur barlvi brother, why. mainy chisti sab ko kaha tha k apni barelvi bahi ko samjay mager us k baad pher barlvi ki bost ayi. app ki ankhan band kun ho jati hain. Manazara k rules first apny barelvion ko parahain then talk to me. I thing you well understand what i meant to say.

Qadri attari, Mainy tum say bar bar bar bar aik he sawal kia ha, k tum log Hazrat Mohammad SA ko noor mantay ho yan bashir-insan. agar tum noor manty ho tou pher hawaly ki baat he nahe rahti aur agar tumhara aqeeda ha k Hazrat Mohammad SA Insan-Bashir hain aur Doebandi nay ghalat lekha ha then HAWALY ki zarurat hoti ha. magar ye baat tumhari moti akal main nahe arahe. baki baan karni ki damki he tum dysakty ho magar mari baat ka jawab b 2 Tell me what is barelvi aqeeda why are u not telling me i am only talkin tell me your aqeeda listen again what is your aqeeda about do you thing Hazrat Mohammad SA is noor?

Qadri attari, Mainy tum say bar bar bar bar aik he sawal kia ha, k tum log Hazrat Mohammad SA ko noor mantay ho yan bashir-insan. agar tum noor manty ho tou pher hawaly ki baat he nahe rahti aur agar tumhara aqeeda ha k Hazrat Mohammad SA Insan-Bashir hain aur Doebandi nay ghalat lekha ha then HAWALY ki zarurat hoti ha. magar ye baat tumhari moti akal main nahe arahe. baki baan karni ki damki he tum dysakty ho magar mari baat ka jawab b 2 Tell me what is barelvi aqeeda why are u not telling me i am only talkin tell me your aqeeda listen again what is your aqeeda about do you thing Hazrat Mohammad SA is noor?

iamnajdi apni is post (your post) ================================= Qadri sab, joth kun boltay ho, tumnay mujko IAMNAJDI lekh ha app ko chahay Padri lekhain ya hindo i know k app koe farak nahe parta aur par b kun but i do not like this. Iamhanfi only hanfi. App shayad mujy damagh say khali legtay ho. kud es post par ap barelvi mujy say sawal kartay ho aur jab main jawab mangta hoon then reply this is not related post. come and see Sajjad khan reply so and soon. if you want to discuss here then do not say what sajhad khan is posting because i never say like this what barelvi posting on other site. if do not want to discuss here then do not post me again for reply so tell me your final discussion talk here or related topic. i hope this should you to the point answer

Padri sab, Ap nay apni kitabain nahe pari, jis main Ahmed raza nay lekh ha Ulma Mahteen Shah ismail ko kafir na kahen yehe sawab ha. agar nahe para tou main post kardyta hoon

Jinab chesti Padri sab, mainy app say pocha tha kia app ka aqeeda kia ha app Hazrat Mohammad SA ko noor mantay hain yan bashir-insan. wohan eys open karka study karain, wohan mentioned has k barelvi Hazrat Mohammad SA ko nooor mantay hain kia ye darust ha. ??????? Magar app hawla talab karahay hain agar app noor nahe mantay then main app ko hawala be dunga agar app noor mantay ho tou phir hawala kun darkar ha. so please confirm me did you accept Hazrat Mohammd SA is noor or not. tumnay Ashraf ali thanvi ki baat ki tou padri sab es topic par be app say baat hogi kuch sabar karain. mager mujy wo jawab dain jo baat horahe ha. kia app Hazrat Mohammad SA ko noor mantay ho yan bashir-insan. jawab usbaat ka do jis first jis par baat horahe ha. main tumko tumhari he books say baton ga k Gustlkhay Rasool kon ha. tum barelvi kitnay pary Gustakhay Rasool ho ye agay baat ho gi but this time reply me which i need. ab ye mat kahna k es pa alag topic hain woha baat karoo

Chisti Qadri, Aik baat tou saf saf zahar hogai k app log kisi ki tashbi dynay ko gali nahe samaj tay no problim Salar Raza Kuttay jaisa ha aur app be aik Kharish zaida kutty jaisay hain, ab tou app ko koe problim nahe ha na. mainy b tashbi di ha, Baki ye baat Salar raza nay yehan par some topic post kar kay baat start ki thi app ki post k baad magar apni dafa ap ki ankhan andi ho jati hain, mainy reply baad main kia tha. App nay kuch Ibarat lekh ka kuch comments dia ((aur kabhi Naoz o Billah chumar say b zayada bad tar samjana,yeh batain kya tumhari samaj main nahi aaty?????? )) harat ha app par aur app kay nam nihad mujadad par k phir b Shah ismail ko muslim kahty ho bilkay mana kartay ho k Shah Sab ko koe kafir na kahay this is right path aur ye he sahi ha yeh batain kya tumhari samaj main nahi aaty??????, apni kitabain kun nahe app log party jis main, malfuzat min ha Alwaheyat zary Qudarat nahe warna wo be ata kardi jatai (word like this) Ahmed raza ki Itabay sunnat ko dekh kar SUhaba Rasool ko dykhnay ka shock kam hogaya. Ahmed raza ka apna din jo unki kitaboon say sabit ha, Allah Tala ko Hazar nazir janna baydini ha etc aur bohat hain, Kia aisi ibrat apni kitaboon main parnay say ap ki ankahan chundya jati hain. magar this is not topic for this i know it magar app kay Salar raza shayd bool jatay hain.

Salar Raza, tum tou shayad aqal say kahli ho. Tum nay ka k main taveelain dyna start kar di hain, tum nay mairi puri baat nahe pari mainy kaha tha k I am not movli or student of any madaras but instead of this I am here to discuss with you one your site but you barelvi even I know some of your well known names do not have courage to discuss on deoband site lihaza apnay baat ko samah kar kia karo. You said you are also common man and the different between you barelvi and deoband is that I am on your site but you can not be on our deoband site even your elder also. Malang bahi aur sajjad khan ko tou app log band kar he chuko ho. Aur mairi wo post jis main aik bidati barelvi nay IBN Kasir ko bidati kaha app logon nay wo b delete kar di aur mujy challenge kia k batao khan ham barelvion nay ibn kasir ko bidati kha magar Allah HAQ wallon k sath ha, wo past hamnay ihtiyatan save karli jo baad main phir dobar mainy post ki. Ye hall ha ap logon ka yakenan JOTHON PAR ALLAH KI LANAT HO. Salar raza tum nay kah k barelvion nay mujko gali nahe di mujy Kutta lekha gaya if this is not gali then tum apny name ka sath Salar raza Kutta lekha karo. So Salar raza kuttay ab dosari baat kartain hain, (jo alfaz barelvion nay mairy lia use kia wo he lekhoon ga) agar Salar Raza kuttay tum main itni hammat hoti to beoband ki site par be ja kar dicuss kartay magar kautty tum main itni hammat nahe 1) Salar Raza Kharshi kyttay Mainy kaha tha ki ye barelvion k aqeeda ha jo mainy para ha so tell me app barelvi Hazzart Mohaammd SA ko noor mantay ho yan basher tumhara jawab apni moot app hoga. Baki tumam topic par be baat ho gi magar one by one so salar raza kharshi kuttay jawab dyna. (Karishi kutty kay alfaz barelvion nay mairy liya use kia aur Salar raza nay kaha y gali nahi so I use this word for Salar Raza). Kitabat ki ghalti ki muazrat[/font]

Shahid Nazir, Tum say mairi mukhalafit ha because i am hanfi but ye baat karkay tum nay Salar raza ki maan mardi.

Qadri Sab, app barelvion main aik bohat bari broblim ha, apny Mujadad wali zuban start kar dyty ho. pls manner main rah kar baat karain. mainy app say sawal kia tha, aur kaha tha k post main study kar loon ga, mager app main himat nahe k jawab dysakain. koe baat nahe. App ki post kay mutabak jo KAWA halal aur Haram khata ha wo Halal ha to eat, Hamray city main b Kawa ha, haram b khata ha aur halal b mager color black ha, shakari be nahe karta tou kia wo halal ha to eat because fika main aisi koe sharat nahe k color sirf white he ho, agar ha then pls post it. pls pls mairay sawal ka jawab dyna kisi k page scan kar k post maat karna.

Qadri sab, ye attachment tou main study kar loon ga but app jawab daity howay kun gabratay ho. pls question ka jawab yes or no main lekh dain, i will be thankfull to you IF A CROW EAT HALAL AND HARAM FOOD THEN THAT CROW IS HALAL TO EAT ANSER:? 2) Kia tota(parat) khana halal ha. Answer:?

shaid sab, you are right in this mater but as concern shair then you should asked barelvi for its explaination then say any thing

Salar Raza: Jab barelvion ko ayina dekhaya jata ha tou wo pagal ho jatain hain kuch hosh nahe rahta. Salar Raza wohe tum nay kia. Jis tarah tumhara baap Ahmed raza gali galoch karta tha, tum uskay rutbay ko tou nahe pohanch saktay magar tum nay try zarur ki ha {(I appreciate, dear viewer you can read book Subhanal Sabu to see how ahamed raza abouse (gali galoch karta tha)}. Mainy koe new topic start nahe kia tha jo barelvion k mutalak para post kardia. Because diyal Shankar kun sara credit lay jay magar app tou bohat bura maan gay balkay bohat he zaida bura maan gay koe baat nahe aisa tou hota ha aisy kamoon main. Tum nay Hussain Ahmed Madni ka shair post kia aur comments diya. Ho jahaloon kay sardar (es site k) you know very well ever verse has deferent meanings which meaning you are taking tell me where Hussain Ahmed Madni accept this and explain that Hazrat ali is muskal kasha like brealvi and shia aqeeda. =============KIA TUM ES BAAT KO CONFIRM KARTAY HO KAY HAR SHAIR KA ZAHARI MATLIB HE LIYA JAY GA CHAHAY SHAIR AHMED RAZA KA HE KUN NA HO aur jo shair main Ahmed Raza kay post karoon ga tum be uska zahri matlab qabool karo ga koe taveel nahe 2gay. do not worry es ka lia main alag topic start karoon ga but confimation tum es post par 2 ============== tum ko chaheya tha k jo post mainy ki us ka jawab daytay mager tum nay galian start kardi. TELL ME JO POST MAINY KI HA KIA WO TUMAM TUMHARY AQEEDAY NAHE HAIN. MAINY SAWAL KIA HA JAWAB DAINA SAWAL PAR SAWAL NA KARNA. I have courage to here in you website and discussing even I am not molvi or not student of any madrisa I am working as an operation Manager in a company. I only study FIkA in Graduation. I know (kuch na kuch) how we should take the meaning of a poem or a verse, there is at least 3post where I did not receive reply of my question still pending from weeks but you do not have courage to go on deoband site and discuss. Doaband kay meaning be note kar loo, wo loog jo tum jaisay shiyateen/ Deo ko band karkay rakhtain hain. Doebandi kahlatain hain (according to me) AB AGAR BAAT KARNI HO TOU TAMEEZ KAY DAIRA MAIN RAH KAR KARAIN (MAGAR SHARAM TUMKO NAHE ATTI)

Kia he acha ho agar tum jawab apny dil say talab karo, waisy Shankar nay kuch ghalat nahe kaha, app barelvi sab kuch kartay ho aisa he, mainy aik site par barelvi aur shia ka takabali jaiza para tha post kar raha hoon app k lia