Naqi Ali Alaihirama Ka Tarjume Me Huzur Ki Taraf Gunah Ki Nisbat Ka Aitraz

[shahabuddin quazi]

devbndio aur wahabio madario ne ye aitraaz alahazrt k trjuma aur unke walid k trjuma e quran k apsi takrav pr kia h... iska jwab maine doonda lekin mujhe nhi mila..

 

iska jwab agr forum me alg se aajay to search krne walo ko asani ho jayengi...

 

AITRAZ.....

 

《 AHMAD RAZA KHAN K ABBA G MOLVI NAQI ALI KHAN PY MOLVI MEHBOOB ALI KHAN AOR MOLVI HSHMAT ALI KHAN KA KUFAR KA FATWA

 

 

Molvi Mehboob Ali Khan( inhon ny e Hadaiqe Bakhsish hissa 3 murattub ki thi) ny 1 kitab likhi jis ka naam hy

 

An-Najoome Shahbya iss kitab ki Khas baat ye hy k iss kitab py 50 sy zayed jayed Brelvi Ulma ki tasdeeqat hen

 

Iss kitab main Deoband k tarajum py AItraaz kiya giya hy

 

Iss Kitab k safha 44,45 py Molvi Mehboob ALi Khan ny Shaikh ul Hind Molana Mahmud Hassan k Tarjuma e Quran py aitraaz karty howy Surkhi Qaim ki hy

 

"Hazoor Syedna Muhammad ﺻﻠﯽ ﺍﻟﻠﮧ ﻋﻠﯿﮧ ﻭ ﺍﻟﮧ ﺳﻠﻢ ki Toheen"

 

Aor Juzve no 4 main Sorahe Fateh ki Ayat ka Tarjuma likha hy

 

"TA K MAAF KARY ALLAH JO AAGY HO CHUKY TRY GUNAAH OR JO PICHY RAHY"

 

Molvi Mehboob Ali Khan ny iss Tarjuma main "Gunah" ki Nisbat Huzoor ﺻﻠﯽ ﺍﻟﻠﮧ ﻋﻠﯿﮧ ﻭ ﺍﻟﮧ ﺳﻠﻢ ki taraf karny ko Huzoor ﺻﻠﯽ ﺍﻟﻠﮧ ﻋﻠﯿﮧ ﻭ ﺍﻟﮧ ﺳﻠﻢ ki Toheen kaha hy aor aagy isi kitab k safha No 54 py likha hy :

 

AOR TOHEENE RASOOL YAQENAN KUFRE SAREEH HY"

 

Maloom howa aesa tarjuma karna Molvi Mehboob Ali khan aor 50 sy zayed jayed Brelvi Ulma k Nazdeek Huzoor ﺻﻠﯽ ﺍﻟﻠﮧ ﻋﻠﯿﮧ ﻭ ﺍﻟﮧ ﺳﻠﻢ ki Toheen hy aor Toheen e Rasool Kufre Sareeh hy

 

Ab Aty hen Ahmad Raza Khan k Abba jan Molvi Naqi ALi Khan ki taraf Molvi Naqi ALi Khan ny 1 kitab likhi

 

"AL KALAM UL OUZAH FI TAFSERE ALAM NASHREH"

 

iss kitab k SFHA 62 Py molvi Naqi Ali Khan ny bhi iss ayat ka Tarjuma krty howy Gunah ki Nisbat Huzoor ﺻﻠﯽ ﺍﻟﻠﮧ ﻋﻠﯿﮧ ﻭ ﺍﻟﮧ ﺳﻠﻢ ki taraf ki aor wesa e Tarjuma kiya jesa Shaikh ul Hind Mahmud Hassan ny kiya

 

To agr aesa Tarjuma karny sy Molana Mahmud Hassan Toheen k Murtakib howy hen to Molvi Naqi ALi Khan bhi 50 sy zayed brelvi Jayyed Ulma k Nazdeek Toheen k murtakib thehry

To Molvi Mahbob Ali Khan o Molvi Hashmat Ali Khan aor 50 sy Zayed Brelvi Ulma k Nazdeek Molvi Naqi Ali Khan Tohene Risalat k murtakib ho kar Kufaar k Ghaht utar gye.. 》

Edited 1 دسمبر 2015 by shahabuddin quazi

[Saife Raza Sunni]

Koi jawab nahi dega bhai

.

Yaha sunniyo ki help koi nahi karta sirf side bana diya islami mehfil, are bhai help karo

[aaftab]

as salam alaikum

 

bhai yei site bana di hai yei bhe buhat bara kaam hai is say bahtar site mai nay aaj tak nahe daikhi .. ham saray yaha talib e ilam he hain ..

 

chand aalim hazrat kay alawa jo maharbani kartay hain apnay qeemti waqt say time nikal kay jo posts un ki nazar say guzarti hai us ka jawab likh daitay hain yei un ki mahrbani hai ham par .. 

 

ziada jaldi howa karay tu kisi darul ifta ya mufti say rabta kar lia karian aur wo jawab yaha bhe likh dia karain takay ham sab ka faida ho ..

aur jaha tak mujhay yaad parta hai kahe mai nay isi forum pay yei aatairaz aur us ka jawab pahlay bhe daikha hai .. search karain mil jaiay shayad

[Abdul mustafa92]

Jitna is site say faida howa hai kisi site say nahi howa jawab na milne ka matlab ye nahi kay site hi ko bura keh do jitna is site kay logo nay kaam kiya hai kisi aur nay kiya ho tu dikha do

Mumkin hai jawab dene wale masroof hun....hussne zan rakho bhai

[Kilk-e-Raza]

shahabuddin quazi sahb, deobandi madhab jhoot pr mushtamil hay. unke kayi etarazat aise hote hain jo ke bat asal kitab men kuch or hoti hay mger ye usko naqal kisi or terha kerte hain. balke deobandyon ke naam nihad munazireen ne tu Alahazrat per fiqah e hanafi ke baz masail per challenge kr ke etarazat kye jinka jawab issi forum per fatawa aalamgiri waghera se dya gaya tu sanp songh gaya..

 

ap ne etaraz pedha or yahan post kr diya. apko chahye ke deobandyon se asal kitab ka aqas mange balke kitab ke 2/3 pages mange ke dekha jaye ke kya waqayi aisi ibarat mojod hay. ager hay tu woh kis context men hay. kaheen Molana naqi ali khan kisi or ki ibarat tu naqal nahi kr rahe or aage uska jawab dya ho.. Nez molana mahbob ali khan ki kitab ka bhi aqas mange..

 

Yahan pr aksar etaraz ke sath deobandi kitab ka scan dya jata hay.. uske bawajod baz dafa deobandi agle pichle page ka scan mangte hain.. tu sunniyon ko bhi chahye ke etaraz per pori tassali keren, take ager yeh jhoot bol rahe hon tu jhoot woheen pakra jaye. or ager scan provide kr den tu phir yahan pr topic post keren scans ke sath. Take jawab dene wale ko aasani ho.

[AqeelAhmedWaqas]

 

 

Already answered.

 

http://www.islamimehfil.com/topic/24523-deobandi-aetaraz-agle-pichle-gunah-muaaf-ka-tarjuma-ahlesunnat-ulema-ne-bhi-kya/#entry103974