Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Abdullah Yusuf

Ijma Ka Maslah

3 posts in this topic

Mere pas aitrazat aye hain quran ki kuch ayat ko le kr 
AB jo maine dalail parhe hain un main in ayat ki tafaseeren or mufasireen k aqwal bhi parhe hain or bohat mushkil se in aitrazat ko khatam kiya hai lekin ab bohat bara maslah paida huwa hai

WOH MASLAH YEH HAI K JIN AYAT KI TAFSEER MAINE PARHI HAIN OR MUFASIREEN K AQWAL PARHE HAIN UN MAIN JAMHOOR MUFASIREEN K AQWAL MAIN GHALTI HAI UNHON NE GHALAT TAFSEER KEE HAI US AYAT KI JAB K
1 YA 2 MUFASIREEN AESE HAIN JINHON NE UN TAMAM MUFASIREEN KI GHALTI KO THEEK KIYA HAI OR USKA RAD KIYA HAI

AB MUJHE YEH SAMAJH NAI AA RAHI K JAMHOOR KA IJMA KAISE GHALAT HO GYA THA
JAMHOOR MUFASIREEN GHALAT KAISE HO GAYE 
OR AB HUM UN JAMHOOR MUFASIREEN KA IJMA MANEN GE YA SIRF UN 2 MUFASIREEN K AQWAL PER AMAL KREN GE JINHON NE JAMHOOR IJMA KA RAD KIYA HAI

NOTE:_(JIN 1 YA 2  MUFAISREEN NE JAMHOOR IJMA KA RAD KIYA HAI WOHI SAHI AQWAL HAIN) 
MATLAB JAMHOOR IJMA GHALAT HAI

Edited by Abdullah Yusuf

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Apny Konsi Ayaat ki tafaserr parhi hy.. jin mein apko laga k jamhoor khata pe hain..
Zara us bary mein Wazahat krain. phir hi kuch kaha ja sakta hy..
Kun k ho sakta hy k ap theak se samjh na payain hon..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ab yahan se masail dekhte hain k Nasikh wal Mansukh k maslah main ULAMA KARAM MAIN KITNA IKHTALAF HAI

Ibn khuzayma ne kaha k 113 quran ki ayaten mansukh ho gaye hain is ayat ki wajah se QURAN KI SURA 9 AYAT 5
IS AYAT MAIN hai K JAHAN BHI KUFAR KO PAO UNHEN QATAL KR DO

 

1.Ab ibn khuzayma kehte hain k is ayat se tamam woh ayaten jin main aman or sakoon ki baten hain woh sab mansookh ho gayen hain ibn khuzayma k nazdeek mansookh ho gayen hain

2.Imam jalaludin sayuti bhi tafsir jalalayn main yehi kehte hain k is ayat (9:5) se tamam aman or sakoon ki ayaten mansookh ho gayen hain

3.Imam ibn kaseer bhi yehi kehte hain k is ayat ki wajah se surah tauba sura 9 ayat 5 se tamam aman or sakoon ki ayaten mansookh ho gayen hain
 

ab in 3 imamon k ilawa imam ZARKASHI FARMATE HAIN JO LOG YEH KEHTE HAIN K IS AIK AYAT KI WAJAH SE WOH AMAN OR SAKOON WALI TAMAM AYATEN MANSOOKH HO GAYEN HAIN WOH SAB GHALAT HAIN KYUNKI JIS WAQT IN MUFASIREEN NE YEH TAFSEER KEE US WAQT IS AYAT KI TAFSEER SAHI NAI KEE GAYE THEE.

AB IMAM ZARKASHI NE IN SAB KA RAD KR DIYA TAU AB KIS KI BAAT MANI JAYE GE JAMHOOR TAU AIK TARAF OR IMAM ZARKASHI KA QOL AIK TARAF.

DOOSRA MASLAH

                              Nasikh wal mansukh per tamam imam or ulama karam ka ikhtalaf dekhen ab 

 

Imam jalaludin sayuti kehte hain sirf 20 ayaten mansookh huwin

Imam ibn khuzayma k nazdeek 113 ayaten mansookh huwin

Shah abdul haq muhadis dehlvi k nazdeek sirf 5 ayaten mansookh huwin

OR BHI BOHAT SARE MUFASIREEN KA APAS MAIN IKHTALAF HAI K KITNI AYATEN OR KONSI AYATEN MANSOOKH HUWIN AB KIS KI MANI JAYE GE 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.