اعتراضات:عقیدہ ایصال ثواب

[smharoon]

Assalam U Alikum

 

Alhumdullilah I am sunni but these few books have made me confused

 

AP APNE SAWAL AOR AITERAZAAT YAHAN POST KER DEIN .. WEBSITES KA LINK DENA YAHAN ALLOW NAHI. AP SAWAL KERNE KI BIJAYE 6 WEBSITES KI ADVERTISMENT KER RAHE HEIN.

Assalam U Alikum

Allah Hafiz

[Ghulam e Azhari]

Wa'alaikumussalam.

 

Brother smharoon, please do not post the links of deobandi sites/books.

 

Secondly, you should mention clearly what your confusion is about a perticular topic.

 

See this article by Kazmi Shah sahib (Rahmatullah Alaih):

http://www.islamieducation.com/ur/افادات-کاظمی/esal-e-sawab.html

 

Please read this article of book Ja-Alhaq:

http://www.islamieducation.com/ur/%D8%B9%D9%82%D8%A7%D8%A6%D8%AF-%D8%A7%DB%81%D9%84%D8%B3%D9%86%D8%AA/behs-fatiha-teeja-daswan-chaleswan-ka-bayan.html

 

The same article in english:

http://www.islamieducation.com/en/ja-al-haq-beliefs-of-ahlesunnah/fatiha-3-days-10-days-and-40-days.html

[smharoon]

Assalam U Alikum Warahmatullah

 

Let me summarize the contents, they say all peoples are bound by their own doing and not others. They say aqeeda of Isaal e Sawab is against Quran there are lots of Ayats describing this specially Najam :39, Sajda:46, Toor:31

 

More they quote

Yaseen:36 : Only you would get for what you have done

Baqra 286

Zamar 39 etc

 

And Say only three work will benefit the deceased

Sadqa Jaria

Ilm e Nafia and

Supplication of children of same.

 

Only Niyabat and Astagfar is possible from others.

 

They say Riwayat about Sadqa, Salat, Saum(Roza), Hajj, Pieces from trees etc are Muztarib and only refer to Niyabat (Vice).

 

 

The links I send were about Fitna Javed Ahmed Ghamidi. To now about it listen Fitna of Javed Ahmed Ghamidi by Mufti Muhammad Haroon Qadri

 

http://www.faizaneraza.org/download-audio...p?t_id=361

 

Also read page # 30

http://library.faizaneattar.net/Books/index.php?id=517

 

I just want to mention that I have read the articles about Esaal e Sawab by Sunni Ulemas but they are the proof and not the answer to their objection, the links of the few of them are given below

 

English:

http://www.deenislam.co.uk/me/khatam.htm

http://www.alahazrat.net/library/eng...esalesawab.htm

http://www.islamicacademy.org/html/A...isaleSawab.htm

http://www.sufi.co.za/article%20okar...%20sawaabt.htm

 

Urdu:

http://www.ja-alhaq.com/urdu-section...ahi-alaih.html

Also A book By Allama Nisar Ahmed Misbahi "Esaal e Sawab Ka Suboot Quran aur Hadith Say"

And a book "Esaal e Sawab Sunnat Hay"

 

What I wanted was an article refuting the objections(By Sunni Alim) raised by misled peoples about it (if in urdu it will be much better) or I will start compiling(Combining material from many places) one, is there anybody ready to type in urdu?.

 

Assalam U Alikum Warahmatullah

[Ghulam e Azhari]

Wa'alaikumussalam.

 

Bhai jaan, I had matched the references given by you, but one Surah Najam verse 39 was correct, rest were incorrect.

 

Surah Najam verse 39, about this Hazrat Ibn Abbas (Radi Allahu Anh) says that this verse is been Mansookh (annulled) by the verse of Surah Toor ayat 21.

(Tafseer Khazain un Irfaan)

 

Now, Sadqa, Saum, Umra (etc), if they say it is Haram to present them for Isal e Sawab then simple this is that they should provide correct evidence from Qur'an and Sunnah that these acts are forbidden for Isal e Sawab. One cannot apply the verdict of Haram with his own wish, but with correct evidences. Our evidences are clear in our books/booklets. Alhamdulillah, they should answer are proofs as well.