Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Muslima

Hazrat Ameer Moawiyah(Radiallah Anhu) Pe Etrazat K Jawab

5 posts in this topic

Asallamoalaikum: Dosto mene Mufti awais sahab ki kitab apne blog par lagai thi . Hazrat-e-Amir muwaviya par ilzamat ka jawab. Us par kuch dosto ne mujhe ye objections pesh kiye hain.

Ye raha book ka link

http://makashfa.word...wabat-urdubook/

 

Now i am pasting objections and review from some minhaji brothers and sisters

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

M reading this book !

I dnt know Maulana Sahab nain Fabricated Ahadith q Daali hain book main !

--------------------------------

Page number 13 par Ibn e Asaakir ki rawayat di hui hay jis main k AAP SAW nain famraya k tmhari Ali k sath ladai ho gi us k bad ALLAH say Afuw aur Bakhshish aur Khushnuwdi..... (Is Hadith ki sanad main Mash-hoor Kazzab rawi hay jo Ahadith gharta tha)

-------------------------------------

Page 14 par hay...

Toraat Shareef main hay..

"NABI SAW Makkah main paida hongy, Madeenah Hijrat Farmaen gay aur Saltanat Shaam main hogi."

 

Inna lillahi Wa Inna Ilahi Rajiun !

Jis Sutnate k bary main AAP SAW nain farmaya:

Nabuwwat ki KHilafat mery bad 30 Saal hogi.. us k bad Mulukiyyat hogi..

 

Ab isi Hadith ko Safeena Abu Abdul Rahman R.A nain bhi rawayat kiya jo Tirmidhi main ai hay !

Aur us k bad yeh hay k unsy Pucha gaya.

 

قال سعيد: فقلت له: إن بني أمية يزعمون أن الخلافة فيهم؟ قال: كذبوا بنو الزرقاء بل هم ملوك من شر الملوك

 

Said (Rawi) kehty hain k mana (Safeena) say pucha k Banu Umayyah sochty hain un k haan khilafat hay? Unhoun nain kaha: Wo jhut bolty hain, Balky un k buri mulukiuyat main say mulukiyyat hay...

 

(jami Tirmidhi)

---------------------------------------

or yeh sirf kitab hi nahi likhi ja raheen, unko katib-e-wahi banaya ja raha hay jiska kisi sahih hadith ki roo se koi base nahi hay.

 

 

 

in logo nay kabhi mola ali ki shan mai aik page nahi likhi hogi - aap research karkay deykh lain mai daway se keh rahi hu

=====================================

Page 29 check karain !

 

"Shia murtad hain"

 

Murtad to Wajib ul Qatl hota hay.... Yani Shia Wajib ul Qatl hain sary???

========================================

 

 

Ab ek aur dandi dykhain !

Puri book main Musnad Ahmad ki Ahadith ko defend karty aay hain k yeh Hasan Ahadith hain sab sahi hain sabit hain (jo k mera bhi believe hay)

 

Aur page number 39 par Sawal karny waly nain musnad Ahmad kaa hawala day diya to us k raawiyun par taan kar k usy Daif sabit karny par tul gaay hain....

 

yani Shamsul Musannifeen apny hi Criteria say phir gaay !! :|

==========================================

 

Page number 15 par Musnad Ahmad ki Ahadith ko defend kiya gaya hay k iski tamam ahadith hasan hain...aur sahi k darjy par hain koi b aysi weak nahi hay jisy reject kiya ja sky....

 

Aur page 39 sawal number 5 k jawab main Molvi Sahab nain musnad Ahmad ki hadith ko weak sabit kiya hua hay aur us k rawiyun par taan kiya hua hay....

 

Yeh kysy 2 rangi hay???

=====================================

1. Kazzab rawi ki hadith qabil e Qubool kab say ho gai?

2. Yeh Ek jaga page 15 par musnad ahmad ki ahadith ko hasan aur sahi kaha gaya hy Tamam ahadith ko aur page 39 main sawal 5 kmjawab main Musnad ahmad ki hadith par sakht Taan kiya hua hay....

======================================

p khud bataen k Kazzab rawi ki ahadith qubool hoti hain ya nahi?? Ap Tahqeeq karain khud b...

 

Yeh kitab full of maudu rawyat hay..

Ek taraf hadith e daif hi nahi balky maudu ko b qubool krty hain aur dusri taraf hadith main aur waqyaat main waekness nikal k reject krty hain..

 

Criteria 1 hona chahiye

=============================

Ye book ki us hadith ki pics hai jo book se li gayi hain book ka link oper mene de diya hai already

Bhaiyon in sawalon k jawabat agar mil jain to inayat hogi. Thx

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

post-3206-0-36074300-1354888198.jpgpost-14208-0-14298000-1354389575.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

bahi humarey pas sahih bukhari ki aik hadees mojood he jis me he k Nabi pak (saw) ne femaya mera(saw) ye beta hazrat hasan r,a musalmano k do bare girho me sulha kerwaye ga...

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

bahi humarey pas sahih bukhari ki aik hadees mojood he jis me he k Nabi pak (saw) ne femaya mera(saw) ye beta hazrat hasan r,a musalmano k do bare girho me sulha kerwaye ga...

 

Ji bhai ap ne sahi farmaya lekin again mene jo questions kiye hain unka answer koi Mufti sahab ya Jirah wa ta'deel k koi students he de sakte hain . i am still waiting for some proper reply

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0