MOUWAHID

Hazrat Isa (Alaih Salam) b MindoNillah hain aur yeh main nahi Quran ka faisla hai...Ab Quran per b Ilzaam lagao agar tum main Ghairat hai! Surah Al-Mai'da Ayat No:115

Chal main teri baat maan laita hoon!Phir Iesai Hazrat Isa(Alaih Salam) ko pukaartay hain to kia woh sahi pukaartay hain...?Aur Makkah k mushrik HAzrat Ibrahim (Alaih Salam) ko pukaartay thay to sahi pukaartay thay?

'Mindunillah' ka matlab kia hai? Allah k siwa koi b ho.. ..Agar Nabi, Wali, Insaan, Sahabi, Tabi is main nahi aatay to batao k yeh phir Allah hi hoay na?kion k jab Allah k siwa nahi to phir Allah hi hoa in ko Allah b kaha jasakta hai!(Nauz-o-Billah)

Ya Allah Madad Bhai Brailvi hazrat ki baat hi maan laitay hain laikin in say aik request hai keh pehlay apnay aap ko Nabi ka umati to saabit kero!

Main aik aik ker k jawab doon ga us per aap ko agar koi aitraaz ho to aap idhar post ker saktay hain!Aur aap Us Hadees-e-Nabwi ko jo main idhar post keroon ga agar mutafiq hoa to b idhar post kerain k haan hum maan chukay hain ab agla jawab lao!Kion k bahas baray baas ka faida koi nahi Ilmi bahas ho to maza aata hai!

Qadri Sahib aap k jahilana sawaalaat k jawab main aaj hi day doon ga!

Jootay kis k sar per hain yeh to aap ko khoob pata ho ga!Zara apna Green Imam utaar ker daikho saari baat samjh main aa jaya gi.......

Aik aur hawala paisha hai Saif-ul-Islam ka. Tafseel k lia daikhain: http://www.islamimehfil.info/index.php?showtopic=6852 Post# 18

Main b aap ko aap kay hi ghar say Aima Arba k ghair muqalid honay ka saboot daita hoon! Aap k bhai NAvid_Khan sahib yeh maan rahay hain k jo mujtahid hota hai us ko kisi ki taqleed kernay ki zaroorat nahi hotii....Abi ya to Aima Arba ko muqalid maan lo ya Mujtahid! Tafseel k lia daikhain! http://www.islamimehfil.info/index.php?/topic/6950-taqleed/ Post # 19

Aur mairi doosari threads ka tum kia jawab do gay tum un ka jawab kabi b nahi day saktay...

Oye Muaqlado!Qiamat tak tum apni gandi taqleed ka ilzaam Muhadseen Karam ki paak zaataon per saabit nahi ker saktay! Opration waalay thread per is lia jawab nahi dia kion k main to aap k saamanay Hadees-e-Nabvi paish kin to aap nay jawab dia k in ka opration aur post mortum abi ho jaata hai......Jis ka aitraaf aik brailvi(Navid) nay idhar bi kia hai.....Mairi itni himat nahi keh main tumharaya saamanay apnay Nabi (saw)ki Ahadees paish keroon aur tum apni gandi aur ghaleez zabanoon say us k lia aisay ilfaaz use kero....Allah ki pannah jo Ahadees-e-Rasool k lia aisay ilfaaz istamaal kertay hain.... Urdu translation say itna kion bhaagatay ho ?Tum ko pata hai agar hum nay us ki urdu translation idhar post ker di to hum jhootay padh jain gay!

Brailvi lootay kabi b apni makaarion say baaz nahi aain gay! JAo main tum ko challange kerta hoon k jo hawaalay Qadri sahib nay idhar post kia hain (Nawab Sahib) k un main muqalid ka lafaz dikha dain!

Theek hai Qadri Sahib aap nay jo Ibn-e-Tamya(RA) ki book ka hawaala idhar dia hai us ka urdu translation idhar post ker do....

Abu Zaid bhai Allah aap ko Jaza day (Ameen...) Qadri sahib aap ka title hai k "muhadaseen b muqalid thay". Agar sachay ho to Un kay apnay aqwaal yahaan paste kero.Jaisa keh Abu Zaid bhai nay aap say sawaalaat kia hain........Warna un per yeh ganda ilzaam na lagao!Aur tum Qiamat tak yeh baat saabit nahi ker saktay.... Aur Nawab Sadiq humaaray akaabir main say nahi hai.....Aur ibn-e-tamya waalay jo hawaalay aap nay idhar post kia hain maira mutaaliba phir ay wohi hai keh n ki Urdu Translation idhar post kero....

Aur maza tab aata hai jub aap jin aima karam ko muqalid saabit ker rahay ho un k apnay aqwaal idhar paish kero!k hum muqalid thay aur tum b humari taqleed kerna...hum bawlay ghair'muqallid looto se tu kabhi kuch sabit na ho sakay ga, tum Barelwi hi kuch sabit karo!

Qadri Sahib behtar to yeh tha k jo hawalay aap nay Imam Ib-e-Tamya(RA) k idhar dia hain un ka urdu tarjuma b daitay takah sub ko pata chalta keh kia likha hoa hai! Aur jahan tak baat hai kisi k mazhab per honay ki to us say taqleed saabit nahi hoti.

Apnay mouh per Zour dar Tamancha! Brailvio Allah say daro!...Kion Aima Karam per Taqleed jaisa ganda ilzaam lagaatay ho.............

Qadri sahib main wait keroon ga!

To saabit hoa keh humara aeraz sahi hai.....Kion keh jo aeraz humara hai wohi to aap brailvi lougoon ka b hai !

Main to usi ka jawab day raha hoon......Shahid bhai nay yehi araz kia tha keh Imam Abu Hanifa(RA) pooray Quran per aboor nahi rakhatay thay!!!!To aap b to yeh baat maantay ho keh Milad ka zikar Quran main hai laikin Imam Abu Hanifa(RA) saari umer is ko samjhanay say qasir thay..... Agar aap is moozou per baat kerna chahtay ho to idhar main nay aik topic start kia hai jis ka koi b brailvi jawab nahi day saka.. Link:- http://www.islamimehfil.info/index.php?/topic/8790-brailvion-say-aik-sawal/

Aur Qadri Sahib yeh baat hum nahi aap b is baat ko maantay ho......Kion k jo Qurani Ayaat aap Milad-u-Nabi per lagaatay ho un ka to aap k Imam sahib ko pata hi nahi chala ya woh un Ayaat ka mafhoom samjhanay say qasir thay!

Mujhay to is baat per Afsoos hota hai keh jis Imam kay Hanfi,Brailvi itnay munaaqib bian kertay hain.....Un ki b taqleed sahi nahi kertay balkeh kai masloon main apnay imam sahib ko b ghalat keh daitay hain......Ya to poori poori taqleed kero ya na kero......

Shukar hai Brailvi HAzrat main b kisi main ghairat ka maada moujood hai keh kisi nay himat ker k humaari baat ko b qabool ker lia! Aur haan yeh jo tum nay ilzaam lagaya hai na keh hum nay jawab nahi dia to Navid sahib zara apni aankhoon ka ilaaj kerwa lain main nay jo ooper jawaab dia hain woh kisi film ki story nahi balkeh Ahadees-e-Nabvi paish ki hain.....

Theek hai SLAFi bhai......Main wait keroon ga...!

Aitraaz:- Jawaab:- Haath Bhandhanay ki daleel:-