Jump to content
IslamiMehfil

MuhammedAli

Members
  • Content Count

    1,387
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    81

Everything posted by MuhammedAli

  1. salam alayqum, kafi kitaben hen is mozoo par ... thora intizar karen in sha allah jald mill jahen gi ...
  2. Salam alayqum, Dr Saeed Sahib aur moteram Khalil Rana Sahib ki wazahat kay mutabiq mein nay is ibarat ka English mein tarjumah yoon keeya heh: “From them is a fanatical supporters of Gangohi called Ashraf Ali Thanvi. He has written small pamphlet; not even of four pages long. In which he explicitly stated knowledge of Ghayb like of RasoolAllah (sallallahu alayhi wa aalihi was’sallam) like it is possessed by every infant, every lunatic, in fact every animal and every quadruped. And followin is (Shaykh Ashraf Ali Thanvi) the cursed’s statement: ‘If it is correct to attribute knolwedge of Gha
  3. Ala Hadhrat nay farmaya: "phir khiyal karo us nay keun-kar mutliq ilm aur ilm mutliq mein hasr kar deeya aur ek do har janay ..." Meri samaj mein yeh nahin aya kay mutliq ilm aur ilm mutliq mein kia farq heh ... bazahir toh donoon ek hee hen. Dosra Thanvi nay hasr kesay keea ... meri samaj mein yeh ibarat nahin aa rahi. In points ki wazahat kay saath agar kohi Ala Hadhrat ki ibarat ko asaan Urdu mein pesh kar deh toh bot mahirbani hogi.
  4. Is ka jawab pehlay bi deeya thah ... kay esi kohi baat nahin. Deobandi ya Wahhabi esay sawalat kartay hen. Aksar log title par kar chalay jatay hen aur shuba rehta heh ... jis ka nateeja hota heh kay gappoon mein is ko discuss kartay hen ya bayan kartay hen aur issue pehal jata heh. Misaal kay tor par, Thanvi haram zada thah ya nahin? is ko thread ka title bana denh. peech kuch nah likhen ... agar pachas banday is ko paren aur apas mein is question ko share karen kay sawal huwa thah kay thanvi haram zada heh ya nahin ... toh 40wen taq janay say pehlay yeh sach ho jahay ga ... aur sawal kay baj
  5. Earlier while writting account from memory I had confused some details and forgot others over the time I have tried to recall accurately as possible in what sequence the events transpired. After much thinking following section has been revised. I just wish the discusion was recorded in its entirity. It would have been a great way of dealing with all relevent issues. Best of my articles and research has been in produced after debates/discussions because it opens up so many topics to write about. And provides such a wealth of material from opponent it makes it s much more easier to churn out mat
  6. Salam alayqum, Yeh Shah Wali-Allah rahimullah wali baat darust nahin. Shah Ismail Dehalvi jab Hajj par gaya toh wapis Wahhabi ho kar aya thah ... ghaliban Mawlana Umar Ucharvi (rahimullah) say naam likhnay mein khata ho gai jis ki islah ka moqa nah milla. Agar Mawlana rahimullah nay esa haqiqi mantay huway bi likha ho toh phir bi kissi ghalt fehmi ki bina par hoga. Shah Wali Allah rahimullah kay aqahid o nazriat ka un ko ilm nahin huwa hoga. Shah Wali-Allah rahimullah kay aqaid o nazriat ahle sunnat walay hee hen aur un ki kutub say esa sabat heh. Jab haqaiq un kay Wahhabi honay kay khilaaf
  7. Qasim Nanotavi ki ibarat kay tarjumen mein bil zaat ki jaga sayyidi Ala Hadhrat nay aslan ka lafz likha ... magar bey-imanoon ko ihtiraz huwa. Manzoor Nomani nay bila waja ... bil zaat kuch fadheelat nah hogi ... kay jumley mein bil arz mafoom mukhalif leeya ... yehni bil zaat fadheelat nahin bil arz zeroor heh ... aur issee bunyad par baqiyoon nay bil zaat kay tarjumein aslan par ihtiraz keeya ... magar bey-imanoon ko sharm nah aahi ... kuch ka lafz tamam fadheelat ka munkir karta heh bil arz aur bil zaat ka ... jistera jumla ... aap ko yaar kuch aqal nahin ... toh mana huwa bilqul aqal nahin
  8. Safa 131/132 bi parnay kay qabil heh ... is mein Tazir un Naas kay masla imkan nazeer kay baray mein kuch arz huwa heh. Qasim Nanotavi ki ghalt fehmi dekhyeh ... muhaal bil zaat awaliat yehni Nooraniat ki waja say heh keun kay misl woh hoga jis ki awaliat bi sabat ho. Jistera ek aur Ilah ka awal Ilah hona muhaal bil zaat heh istera kissi aur makhlooq ka awal makhlooq hona muhaal heh ... aur awaliat RasoolAllah ki shaan heh toh phir muhaal bil zaat huway ... aur agar satti nazr say dekha jahay toh imtinah bil ghayr wada e bari ta'ala ki waja say heh ... magr haqiqat mein wada illahi kay RasoolA
  9. Qasim Nanotavi nay likha thah Ambiya Ilm Mein mumtaz hotay hen amal mein Ummati barabar ya bar jatay hen. Neechay wali kitab kay safa 74 par likhta heh ilm ladunvi ka talluq tawqa say heh ... Khidr alayhis salam taqwa mein ziyada thay aur Musa alayhis salam kam jis waja say Khidr alayhis salam par teen waqiat ka ilm ladunvi hasil huwa ... Musa alayhis salam sirf Wahi walay ilm mein behtr thay ... aur keun kay Khidr alayhis salam taqwa mein behtr thay is waja say uneh ziyada ghaybi ilm hasil huwa ... https://archive.org/stream/TOOBAA-RESEARCH-LIBRARY.FaraidEQasmiyaMakateebHazratAllamaQasimNan
  10. Agar Sayyidi Ala Hadhrat aur Jamhoor ka awaliyat e Nabuwat wala nazria heh toh phir mujjay kohi bi ihtiraz nahin. Sirf Sayyidi Ala Hadhrat say hi is ka sabat hona meray leyeh kafi daleel heh. Agar yahi ho toh phir is ka matlab yeh huwa kay ... Qasim Nanotavi wala nazria joh Nabuwat bil zaat ka heh aur Ambiyah ko RasoolAllah say Nabuwat milli darust hoga. Sirf Khatam un Nabiyeen ka mana Nabuwat bil zaat hona darust nah hoga aur ijmah kay khilaf khatam un nabiyeen ka mana nabuwat bil zaat karna kufr hoga. Aur us ki ibaraat Nabi peda ho toh phir bi khatamiat mein farq nah ahay ga ... waghayra kuf
  11. Woh laga rahay hen laganay denh. Bhoj bi wohi uthahen gay. Yeh masla firohi heh ... aur fazail say ... Hadith Adam alayhis salam say RasoolAllah kay Nabi awal honay ki daleel nahin leeh ja sakti aur nah mein nay kabi para heh. Is Hadith say sirf yeh mana nikalta heh kay jab Adam (alayhis salam) kay jism e mubarak kii takhleeq ho rahi thee RasoolAllah (sallallahu alayhi wa aalihi was'sallam) ko mansub Nabi milla huwa thah. Allah ta'ala nay Quran mein Misaqun Nabiyeen ka farmaya heh ... Allah nay Nabiyoon ki Arwah ko jama farmaya ... Adam (alayhis salam) kay jism e aqsad say yeh pehlay ki baat h
  12. https://sunnah.com/bukhari/97/59 https://sunnah.com/bukhari/60/19 https://sunnah.com/muslim/12/188 https://sunnah.com/urn/1077550 https://sunnah.com/nasai/37/136
  13. Salam alayqum, Khadim nay kabi esi Hadith nahin pari ... Hadith mein aya heh kay woh musalmanoon ko qatal keren gay aur kafiroon ko chor denh gay magar jis ka aap nay zikr keeya heh woh pehlay kabi nahin suni nah pari ... agar huwi toh ahle ilm hazrat pesh kar denh gay.
  14. Salam alayqum Aqeedah e Khatam e Nabuwat par kohi anch nahin aati. Yeh un ki ghalt fehmi heh. Mein nay kahi dafa Qadiyaniyoon say tehreeri behas ki kabi kohi problem nahin huwi aur nah apna aqeedeh mein tarmeem karna pari. Yeh un ko waswasa heh kay Jamhoor e Ahle Sunnat Alam e Arwah mein Nabi maan kar Qadiyani kay khilaf difa nahin kar saktay.
  15. Salam alayqum, M.Zeeshan Imtiaz bhai mein waqif hoon kay yeh ihtirazaat kahan say ahay. Yeh qabil e lehaz tab hotay jab alam e arwah mein Nabi ko Wahi nah huwi ho. Wahi ka kitabi hona zeroori nahin. Allah farmatay heh kay woh Nabiyoon say farishtoon kay zariyeh baat karta heh toh phir ... jab arwa say sawal huwa mein tumaray aakhir mein Nabi behjoon ga wada kartay ho iman laho gay aur support karo gay toh sab nay iqrar keeya ... yeh kalam bazariya farishtay huwa aur yeh waqia toh Quran mein heh ... abh Wahi toh ho gai. Aur agar Nabi kay leyeh Wahi zeroori ho toh bi sabat ho jaati heh ... si
  16. Following Addition Has Been Made. ----------------------------------------------- What Is Part Of Islam And What Is Not Part Of Islam: Shaykh believes certain prophetic Sunan including Siwak/Miswak are not part of Deen. Yesterday I was sitting down and thinking: Imam Bukhari (rahimullah alayhi ta’ala) collected over around ten thousand Ahadith and so did many other Muhadditheen. Why would Imam Bukhari (rahimullah) travel throughout Islamic world to learn Ahadith and record them in His collection. Picture this: I know Yoga has nothing to do with Islam but I walk it, camel it, horse it, all
  17. Amar Iqbal [12 November 2017 07:22]: Salaam. Hope your in good health and Emaan. You have not explained the concept of good bida and where this is derived from. Many quote Omar (radiallah ta’ala anhu) however this is untrue to attribute the concept being portrayed. Waslaam Muhammed Ali [On 26 Nov 2017, at 12:53]: Salam alayqum. Brother Amar I have revised my earlier articles to improve content and in addition to this if you recall you mentioned Imam Nawavi (rahimullah) said Hadith referrs to prophetic Sunnah and reviving prophetic Sunnahs. As promised I have addressed that claim of yours. Its
  18. Salam alayqum. ----------------------- 1 - Mawlana Saeed Ahmad Assad nay Noor Bashr kay munazray mein jawab deeya thah ... Nabuwat ka mansub mila magr mansub par kaam aakiri Nabi bana kar behja gaya toh phir shoroon huwa. Jistera police walay ko job Lahore ki millay aur rahay Karachi mein ... position to milli magr duty apnay station par hi ja kar deh sakta heh. 2 - Janab Quran mein aya heh kay shahid ki makhi (i.e. Bee) ko Wahi hoti heh toh kia us ko wahi huwi toh woh Nabi ho gahi? Aur Jibraeel alayhis salaam aah kar us ko kitab ka ilm detay hen? Jab Hadith say wazia huwa kay aap Nabi
  19. Salam alayqum, Mein nay pari nahin. Magr andaza heh kay biddat ki tareef mein ikhtilaf par hogi ya jamhoor ki istilah biddat say different hogi joh aaj kal bazahir Wahhabi istimal kartay hen. Biddat ki tareef mein ikhtilaf Ijtihadi Ikhtilaf heh. Yehni aqsar Sunni Ulamah: Biddat Hasanah aur Biddat Zalalah ki taqseem kartay hen. Magr kuch Ulamah is taqseem kay qail nahin. Un kay nazdeeq har biddat gumrahi heh aur Mawlid waghayra Sunnat Hasanah say hen jin ki ijaad ka aur amal ka sawab heh. Woh Mawlid ko Biddat Hasanah nahin tehratay balkay Sunnat Hasanah say gintay hen. Yeh kohi khaas ikhtila
  20. Yeh sirf drama heh ... tamasha ... is kay apnay maulvi Ummat kay jamhoor/majority ko Mushrik/Kafir likh chukay ... yeh banda uneeh kay mazhab ki taraf bulata heh, uneeh ki Takfir e Ummat ki taraf bula raha heh, sirf itihad e ummat ka drama kar kay, aur Sunni bewaqoof aur jahil is kism ki batoon mein aa jatay hen.-jatay hen aur phir ek doh saal Deobandi ho jatay hen aur phir Ismail Dehalvi ki Takfir: Tawheed rare/nayab ho chuki kalmah parnay walay aksir logh mushrik hen ... phir is patti par char chata heh ...
  21. Salam alayqum. Dhul Qurnayn ghaliban ek Yahoodi qom say thay aur Musalman thay yehni Musa alayhis salam kay mannay walay thay. Alexander Mushrik/Kafir thah. Baqi sari kissay kahaniyan hen. Kissi kay pass kuch wazia subut nahin.
  22. Introduction: Brother Amar Iqbal bumped into me in a eatery. We discussed about religious issue of Mawlid, Khatams, Geeyarween and naturally subject turned to topic of innovation. His position, like typical of all Wahhabiyyah was; innovations in Islam are completely prohibited and innovations into Deen are evil/sinful. He quoted Hadith, every innovation is misguidance, to support his position. My response was; if every/qullu is in its Haqiqi meaning then nothing is excluded from it, not Bukhari, and not Muslim. They too would be inclusive, therefore would be innovations and misguidance. His
  23. Introduction: Definition of innovation legitimacy of praiseworthy innovations and engagin in praiseworthy innovations is has become subject of dispute. As a result of this dispute there is great deal of tribulation in Ummah of beloved Prophet (sallalahu alayhi was'sallam). A the extremist faction regularly churns out edicts; brandishing Muslims as innovators and telling them they’re from people of hell. This affliction can not be eliminated until the fundamental cause of tribulation isn't solved and that is the definition of innovation. If two academics attempt to explain their position of
×
×
  • Create New...